Even when you know how to choose your mattress, if you’re on a tight budget, it helps to have a couple of brands and the best mattresses under $500 to start from. We can’t tell you which mattress will be best for you, because it depends on your sleeping position, preferences, and budget, but the following suggestions should give you an idea of what’s out there.
All of these mattresses are fiberglass-free, minimum 10” thick, and made with certified materials, like CertiPur-US foams and Oeko-TEX fabrics, and their price falls under $500/queen. Some of them also have premium features, like cooling and support technology and pillowtop covers. We think you deserve the best and wanted to recommend the best products only.
5 Best Mattresses under $500
1. SweetNight CoolNest™ Foam Mattress
This fiberglass-free all-foam mattress has become a best-seller in just a few months from its launch, impressing even House Digest and Apartment Therapy writers and editors. When you look at its details, you immediately understand why.
First, it’s priced at only $399 for the 12” queen and $469 for the 14” queen. A 16” queen for only $599 is already a miracle. Then, it has impressive cooling, breathability, and support features: patented CoolNest™ cover and PCMflux™ Foam that guarantee cooling and breathability, gel-infused and ocean memory foam, comfort foam, and a 5-zone targeted support system.
While it’s only available in medium firmness, the thinner version will work well for those who need or prefer a firmer mattress. The thicker version is best for those who like a soft, cradling mattress. You can read more about it in my review. Since it’s backed by a 100-night trial and a 1-decade warranty, you really have no reason not to buy. The SweetNight CoolNest mattress is definitely the best foam mattress under $500.
2. Twilight Pillowtop Hybrid
Endorsed by everyone from Sleep Foundation to U.S. News, the Twilight Pillowtop hybrid mattress has raving reviews (4000+ x 4.5/5 stars) and an unbelievable price starting from $419.99 for the 10” queen, depending on thickness and occasional promos. Available in 10”, 12”, and 14” thicknesses, it combines the targeted support of pocketed coils with the pressure relief of memory foam and the cloud-like feel of the pillowtop.
If you’re a back or stomach sleeper, you’ll probably like the 10” option best, as it feels firmer. Side sleepers will likely prefer the thicker options, as they provide a little more bounce and cushioning. With the 14” queen selling for only $499, you really can’t go wrong buying this mattress.
Shop SweetNight Twilight Here!
3. Siena by Resident
At only $359/queen, this 10” mattress is a steal. While it doesn’t seem to have anything spectacular, it does check all key points of the best mattresses known to provide restful and comfortable sleep: cooling, pressure relief, support, and motion isolation. Its 6.5 firmness rating makes it more suitable for back and stomach sleepers, but you know your needs and preferences best. The Siena memory foam mattress comes with a generous 180-night trial and 10-year warranty. There’s also a $50 anti-microbial protection add-on.
4. Vitality 12” Hybrid by Novilla
With a price of $398.99/queen, this hybrid is a bargain, but then, Novilla does have some of the best budget mattresses! The only things missing for the Vitality 12” hybrid to rank higher on our list of best mattresses under $500 is the pillowtop cover and more size and thickness options. Also backed by a 100-night trial and 10-year warranty, it brings to the table increased concern for environmental protection. While Novilla has yet to take on some of the mattress industry giants, it’s impossible not to notice the great value for the money and the raving reviews.
5. Avenco Zone Hybrid Mattress
All Avenco mattresses are insanely affordable, falling well under $500 for a queen. The Avenco Zone costs only $359.99 for a 12” queen. It combines cooling gel, comfort foam, and high-density foam with a 5-zone pocketed springs system to deliver restful sleep on a budget.
Its design is quite neat, and the cover fabric has a nice, knitted texture. My favorite element is the stronger perimeter featuring stronger coils to improve edge support. The Zone won’t match the Twilight, with its pillowtop, cooling, and pressure relief.
But for its price, it’s an excellent deal. I’d especially recommend it for guest rooms and vacation homes, dorm rooms, kids, and teenagers. It may work well in cooler regions where night sweats are not an issue.
When money is tight and you need a new mattress, any of the above five mattress models should work. Their $500 price is easier to cover than the $1000+ price tag of more popular and expensive brands. Sure, durability may not be the same, but you’ll sleep comfortably and gain several years to save for a better mattress.
Why a Low Price Doesn’t Mean Compromise
Is it possible to get a high-quality mattress for under $500? Absolutely. The days when budget mattresses meant lumpy springs or sagging foam are over. Advances in materials and manufacturing have revolutionized the market, making affordable mattresses with premium features available to everyone. Whether you’re a college student setting up a dorm or a homeowner upgrading a guest room, today’s options provide comfort without breaking the bank.
Budget-Friendly Options with Premium Features
Let’s get straight to the point: modern best mattresses under $500 now include features that were once exclusive to luxury models. Cooling gel-infused memory foam? Yes. Zoned support for spinal alignment? Available. Hybrid designs combining coils and foam? Definitely. Brands like SweetNight offer durable materials at prices that surprise.
How Modern Manufacturing Brings Quality within Reach
Streamlined production and direct-to-consumer models cut costs without reducing performance. Many affordable mattresses now skip traditional retail markups, passing the savings to you. Innovations like compressed mattress shipping lower logistics expenses, allowing brands to invest more in quality materials. As a result, you’ll find fiberglass-free CertiPUR-US certified foams in this price range, ensuring safety and longevity.
How do you choose the right option? Start by identifying your sleep style. Side sleepers often need pressure-relieving foam, while back sleepers may prefer hybrid support. The SweetNight Twilight Pillowtop Hybrid Mattress, for example, combines responsive coils with a plush top layer, making it a standout among budget mattress picks for combination sleepers. Hot sleepers should look for breathable designs like the Siena 10” Signature Memory Foam Mattress, which uses open-cell foam to prevent overheating.
Key Factors to Consider
When searching for the best mattresses under $500, keep these essentials in mind:
- Material durability: Look for high-density foams (at least 1.8 lb/ft³) or tempered steel coils.
- Firmness options: Many models now offer multiple firmness levels in one mattress.
- Specialized designs: Need a mattress for a Murphy bed? The 10” Siena model’s low profile is ideal.
Concerned about trial periods? Most brands now offer 100-night sleep trials, even on affordable mattresses. The SweetNight Prime’s 4-in-1 firmness options allow you to test different configurations risk-free. Warranties are also generous, with 10-year coverage common in this price range to protect against premature sagging or defects.
Who Benefits Most from Budget-Friendly Beds?
These mattresses aren’t just for temporary use. With proper care, today’s budget mattress picks can last 7 to 10 years. They’re perfect for:
- Guest rooms needing occasional-use comfort
- Renters who move frequently
- Growing teens needing adaptable support
- Eco-conscious shoppers (many sub-$500 models use plant-based foams)
Still unsure? Over 35% of Wirecutter’s recommended mattresses are now under $500. Industry testing shows that mid-range models often match $1,000+ options in pressure relief and motion isolation. The main difference? You’re not paying extra for expensive marketing campaigns and unnecessary frills like hand-stitched borders or exotic materials.
How to Choose a Good Mattress on a Budget
Navigating the world of best mattresses under $500 requires a strategy. You don’t have to sacrifice quality; you just need to know where to look. This mattress buying guide outlines five essential factors that distinguish lasting comfort from temporary solutions. Here’s what really matters when selecting affordable mattresses that provide value night after night.
Key Considerations for Budget Mattress Shoppers
Support and spinal alignment
When searching for the best mattresses under $500, proper support is crucial. Your mattress should keep your spine neutral whether you sleep on your back, side, or stomach. Side sleepers often need extra cushioning at the shoulders and hips, making memory foam a great choice. If you suffer from back pain, look for zoned support layers like those in the SweetNight Twilight Pillowtop Hybrid. These targeted areas help prevent morning stiffness by aligning joints without creating pressure points.
Materials and construction
Construction quality determines longevity. In affordable mattresses, high-density foam (1.8 lb/ft³ or higher) resists sagging better than cheaper alternatives. Hybrid models combine durable coils with comfort layers, such as the SweetNight CoolNest, which uses three different foam types for balanced support. Latex fans will appreciate the SleepEZ Essential, which offers natural resilience at this price point. Always check for CertiPUR-US certifications, which guarantee safe, durable foams free from harmful chemicals.
Firmness and sleep position
Your go-to mattress buying guide tip: match firmness to your sleep style. Most combination sleepers do well with medium-firm (6-7/10), while strict side sleepers may prefer a softer (5/10) feel. Stomach sleepers should choose firmer options (7.5/10) to prevent hip sinkage. Many modern best mattresses under $500 offer multiple firmness levels. For example, the SweetNight Prime’s flippable design provides four comfort options in one bed, adapting as your needs change.
Motion isolation and edge support
If you share your bed, motion transfer is important. All-foam designs like the Siena 10” absorb movement best, which is ideal if your partner tosses and turns. Hybrids with pocketed coils, like the SweetNight Twilight, also reduce vibrations while adding bounce. Edge support is often overlooked in budget mattress picks, but it matters if you sit on the edge of the bed frequently. Reinforced perimeters prevent that rolling-off feeling and increase usable sleep space.
Cooling and breathability
Hot sleepers will appreciate that today’s affordable mattresses include smart cooling technology. Gel-infused memory foam draws heat away from your body, and breathable covers enhance airflow. Latex naturally sleeps cooler than traditional foam, and the SleepEZ Essential’s open-cell structure promotes constant air circulation. For hybrid lovers, coils create natural ventilation channels.
Durability
Durability is the silent hero of best mattresses under $500. A 10-year warranty is not just a marketing tool; it reflects the brand’s confidence in their product. Look for reinforced edges in hybrids or high-resilience latex layers. The SleepEZ Essential, for example, uses Talalay latex that maintains its shape for years. CertiPUR-US foams in models like the SweetNight CoolNest also ensure you’re not exposed to toxic fumes.
Trial periods
Most affordable mattresses now offer 100-night sleep trials. This allows you to test temperature control and support in real-world conditions. The SweetNight Prime’s reversible design goes even further; flip it if you need firmer or softer support during the trial.
Pro tip: Walk across the mattress during setup. If it feels unstable or uneven, contact customer service right away.
Here’s a key point: thickness matters but it’s not everything. For Murphy beds, slim profiles are important. Choose 10” designs with dense foam bases. Need easy mobility? Hybrids under 12” offer a great balance between comfort and portability.
In summary, the best budget mattress picks balance immediate comfort with long-term performance. Prioritize models that offer sleep trials. 100 nights let you test support and cooling claims without risk. Certifications like CertiPUR-US are important; they prove rigorous safety and durability testing. Whether you choose the pressure-relieving SleepEZ latex or the adaptable SweetNight Prime, these guidelines ensure your under-$500 investment delivers restful sleep for years.
Tips for Getting the Most Value from Your Mattress Purchase
How to Stretch Your Budget Further
Getting the best mattresses under $500 that last takes more than just clicking “buy now.” Here are strategies to turn short-term savings into long-term value. Use this playbook to maximize your investment and avoid buyer’s remorse.
Watch for seasonal sales and discounts
Timing is important. Retailers offer the best mattress deals during Memorial Day (May), Labor Day (September), and Black Friday (November). Pro tip: Sign up for brand newsletters; companies often send exclusive promo codes to subscribers before public sales begin.
Understand return policies and trial periods
Always read the fine print. Trusted brands of best mattresses under $500 offer 100-night sleep trials, giving you enough time to test comfort and support. They also offer free returns, so you won’t need to worry about paying extra to return your mattress if you’re not happy with it.
Use mattress protectors to extend lifespan
A $30 protector can add 2 to 3 years to your affordable mattress. Look for waterproof, breathable models with TPU membranes; they block spills without trapping heat. For allergy sufferers, allergen-proof covers (with OEKO-TEX certification) reduce dust mite buildup by 67%. Most protectors also don’t void warranties when used correctly.
Check for certifications and warranties
CertiPUR-US foam and a 10-year warranty are your safety net. When comparing mattress deals, prioritize models with verified material safety. The SleepEZ Essential’s GREENGUARD Gold certification, for example, means it emits 90% fewer VOCs than uncertified latex. Make sure warranties cover sagging deeper than 1” and material splits.
Maintenance Hacks for Maximum Longevity
Have you chosen your best mattress under $500? Now make it last. Rotate the mattress from head to foot every 3 to 6 months to prevent body impressions in foam layers. For hybrids like the SweetNight Twilight, vacuum around the coils every few months to prevent dust buildup. If you spill coffee, blot stains immediately and use baking soda to neutralize odors.
Decoding Discount Strategies
Retailers aren’t always clear about mattress deals. Watch for these tactics:
- “Exclusive” models: Some stores sell nearly identical beds under different names to prevent price comparisons.
- Bundle traps: “Free” pillows or sheets may hide inflated mattress prices.
- Clearance cycles: New models arrive in January and July, so older stock is discounted 20 to 30%.
Smart shoppers combine discounts with cashback or referral bonuses. Stack a holiday sale code with a referral discount (many brands offer $25 to $50 off for sharing links).
When to Splurge vs. Save
Even with affordable mattresses, some upgrades are worth it. Invest in:
- Edge reinforcement: Essential if you sit on the edge often (look for models with foam-wrapped perimeters).
- High-density bases: Foam with 1.8 lb/ft³ or higher resists sagging better than cheaper alternatives.
- Zoned support: Worth the extra $50 to $75 for chronic pain sufferers.
The Certification Cheat Sheet
Not all certifications are equal. When looking at mattress deals, prioritize:
- CertiPUR-US: Ensures foams are emissions-safe and durable.
- OEKO-TEX Standard 100: Verifies fabric safety (important for protectors).
- GREENGUARD Gold: Indicates ultra-low chemical emissions.
Avoid vague claims like “eco-friendly” without third-party proof. The SleepEZ Essential’s certifications, for example, confirm its non-toxic materials, no guesswork needed.
Warranty Wisdom
That 10-year warranty on your affordable mattress may have loopholes. Protect yourself by:
- Taking photos of the mattress during unboxing (to prove there was no pre-existing damage).
- Using a proper foundation,platform beds or slats no more than 3” apart prevent voided coverage.
- Keeping receipts digitally (email them to yourself with “mattress warranty” in the subject line).
Most best mattresses under $500 start prorating warranties after year 3. For example, SleepEZ covers 100% of defects in years 1 to 3, then decreases coverage by 10% annually. That’s still better than no protection at all.
Final Pro Tips
Your mattress buying guide quick checklist:
- 🛏️ Compare prices across three or more sites using Honey or Capital One Shopping.
- 🌡️ Test cooling claims by sleeping on the bed for at least 14 nights (give materials time to adjust to your body heat).
- 📅 Set calendar reminders for mattress rotation and warranty expiration dates.
- 📦 Keep the original packaging for 30 days in case you need to return the mattress.
Remember, the real test of affordable mattresses isn’t the price, it’s how well you optimize your purchase. Pair a well-chosen model like the SweetNight Twilight with regular maintenance, and you’ll enjoy better sleep than those who spend thousands. Smart choices always beat big budgets when it comes to restful nights.